Proving with Computer Assistance 2IMF15
!! Exam consultation that is: you can see your graded work, on Thursday 2-05-2019, 15:00- 16:00 in MF6.079A !!
Teacher
Herman Geuvers: home page
Room number MF6.079A (only on Thursdays) For contact, use the e-mail address herman at cs dot ru dot nl
Location and time
Thursdays, hours 5-6: ATLAS -1.825 and hours 7-8, Gemini-Zuid Collegezaal (lecture hall).
Prerequisites
We assume that you are familiar with a bit of logic, especially natural deduction and (untyped) lambda calculus.
- For those not familiar with untyped lambda calculus:
I will do a short recapitulation in hour 2 of the Lecture 1. Furthermore, read "Introduction to Lambda Calculus" of
Barendregt and Barendsen, Chapter 1, Chapter 4 pp. 22-26, Chapter 2
pp. 12-14 (read = as beta-equality =_{\beta})
As exercises you may try 2.5 -- 2.10.
Material
System we will use
We will be using the Proof Assistant Coq in this course. You
can download and install Coq locally, but you can also use it through
the ProofWeb webinterface at
http://prover-pca.cs.ru.nl/new. (NB: ProofWeb runs Coq version 8.3.pl4, the latest version that works smoothly with the web interface. A Coq version you download and install yourself will most likely be more recent.)
For ProofWeb:
- Get a login, by sending a mail
- with subject: [pwca], please include the brackets.
- consisting of one line: LoginName,password,Name Student
- to the teacher and he wil create one for you. Note:
Don't use spaces, because a space surrounding "password" will
become part of your password.
- Go to http://prover-pca.cs.ru.nl/new
- Login to "Proving with Computer Assistance 2019"
- Load one of the files (preferably start with
the proposition_logic.v file)
- You can now type in tactics to create proofs in natural deduction. You can also select these from the Templates menu.
- Check "Fitch style natural deduction" in the Display menu, to see the proofs in Fitch style.
- If you don't know what to do, load the file proposition_logic.v and "play" the proofs that are given there.
The course by week
This schedule may be subject to changes!
- 7/2 hour 5-6 Lecture 1 Overview and Introduction: Proof Assistants,
Verification, Logic, Type Theory, Formulas-as-types, Coq.
Short recapitulation of lambda calculus.
- 7/2 hour 7-8 Lecture 2 Simple Type theory and
"Formulas-as-Types" for propositional logic.
- 14/2 hour 5-6 Lecture 3 Dependent Type Theory.
- 14/2 hour 7-8 Lecture 4 Natural Deduction
(proposition logic and predicate logic) in Coq, using ProofWeb.
Be sure to bring a laptop
with wireless internet connection
- All students that have sent me a login request on prover before
February 13, now have a login. Please try it
on http://prover-pca.cs.ru.nl/new. If
you don't have a login, send me a mail (see above).
- Here is
a page
with a list of simple useful tactics
- Proposition Logic: Here is the file with the
proposition logic Coq exercises
of the lecture. Complete this at home and send it to the teacher
by mail by February 27.
- Here is the proposition_log file with
some answers filled in.
- Predicate logic: Here is a file with
the predicate logic Coq
exercises. Complete this (you can skip the "Challenge
problem") at home and send it to the teacher by mail by
February 27.
- Here is the pred_log file with
some answers filled in, also of
the "Challenge problem".
- 21/2 hour 5-6 Lecture 5 The Curry variant of Simple Type Theory:
principal type algorithm.
- Here are the slides of the lecture.
- The first three pages of this document describe the principal type algorithm in detail.
- Make the exercises.
- NB Here are
some answers
to the exercises.
- 21/2 hour 7-8 Lecture 6
Polymorphic Types: ML style and full polymorphism
- 28/2 hour 5-6 Lecture 7
Higher order logic, Calculus of Constructions
- 28/2 hour 7-8 Lecture 8 Inductive Types. Be sure to
bring a laptop with wireless internet connection
- Here are
the
slides
- Here are three files that have been shown at the lecture and you
can load into Coq/Prover:
- Do the files coq_nat_03.v up to coq_nat_10.v on prover
(and coq_nat_11.v if you want a challenge) and send
your solutions to the teacher by mail by March 13.
In case you don't use prover: here is a zip file with all relevant Coq files about nat, list and tree.
Here is the worked out
version of coq_nat_11.v,
where you can also see the use of the omega tactic.
- 7/3 No Lecture, because of Carnaval holiday week.
- 14/3 hour 5-6 Lecture 9
More inductive types; Presentation
of the Coq assignment.
- Read slides 16-18 and 25-32 of
the
slides of last week on inductive types.
- Do the files on lists coq_list_03.v up to coq_list_06.v on
prover and send your solution to the teacher by mail
by March 21.
- Here are the example files, showing how to do the first exercises
on lists in
Coq:
coq_list_01.v
and
coq_list_02.v.
- Here is
coq_list_06.v worked out, with some aditional comments.
- Do the exercises on trees coq_tree_02.v up to coq_tree_04.v on prover and send your solution to the
teacher by mail by March 21.
- Here is an example file, showing how to do the first exercise on
trees in Coq. Look here for the htm-ized file and look here
for the Coq source file.
- Here is a page
about the Coq assignment. Alternative suggestions for the Coq assignment can be found here .
- 14/3 hour 7-8 Lecture 10
Programming with inductive types and dependent inductive types.
- 21/3 hour 5-6 Lecture 11
Examples of cool and useful Coq features + Work on Coq assignment.
Be sure to bring a laptop with wireless internet connection
- 21/3 hour 7-8 Lecture 12
- Work on Coq assignment
Be sure to bring a laptop with wireless internet connection
- Here is a page where an earlier
example assignment has been worked out. It has been created from
a coq .v file .
- We have used the "Proviola" system (by Carst Tankink) to produce this documented page.
- 28/3 hour 5-6 Lecture 13 Work on Coq assignment, opportunity to ask question about the earlier theory-exercises.
- 28/3, hour 7-8 Lecture 14 Work on Coq assignment
- 4/4 hour 5-6 Lecture 15 Recap of all exercises; Treatment of
the exam
of July 2010.
- 4/4 hour 7-8 Lecture 15 Work on Coq assignment
Examination
The mark for the course is determined by the 2
marks you will get for the two items listed below.
- Final mark = (Written Exam mark + Coq Assignment mark)/2
with the condition that your Written Exam mark should be 5 or higher.
Note that you don't receive a mark (so I will write "NV") if you
haven't completed all parts of the course.
- Written exam Monday 8-04-2019, 13:30- 16:30
- The written exam will consist of questions comparable to the ones that were given during the lectures: see above for the pdf files.
- It is an open book exam, so you can bring any paper material you want
- Exam consultation that is: you can see your graded work, on Thursday 2-05-2019, 15:00- 16:00 in MF6.079A.
- Older exams:
- The exam of July 2010.
- Here is the exam of 2008. (NB: the original version, which may still be at the Gewis website, contained a mistake; this is the corrected version.)
For the second chance ("Hertentamen"), all guidelines above apply with the following dates/deadlines:
- Written exam: Monday July 1, 18:00-21:00.
- Coq assignment deadline: Tuesday July 2, 18:00.
Coq Assignments
,
Deadline: Thursday 11-04-2019; do the assignment in couples deliver your assignment by mail to the teacher.
Here is a page about the
of Coq assignment. (Look here
for some additional comments regarding the use of lists.) Options:
- You can do the assignment on the ProofWeb system.
- You can install Coq locally on your machine.
To complete the Coq assignment follow these steps:
- Solve the assignment and write a report (more on that below).
- Deliver your solution (Report + separate Coq .v files) via mail.
A couple of remarks concerning the report:
- Do not make it too long. 15 pages is the absolute maximum but normally it
should be much shorter. Keep in mind that longer does not mean better!
- What you should write:
- Names and student numbers.
- Explanation of the problem and your approach to it.
- Description of the main definitions and the line of your
proofs (e.g. sublemmas you used). If you had some
alternative ideas to solve those problems describe them
and explain your choice for the solution to this
problem.
- Write about your experience with the prover. What did
you like, what you did not like etc.
- Possibly add the Coq code as an appendix. (But note that
you should deliver the Coq .v files separately anyway.)
- What you should not write
- Do not unnecessarily repeat the code. Refer to appendix
and quote the code only to illustrate something.
- Do not write obvious things! Description of the proofs
of the shape:
"the goal is as follows so we apply this tactic and
that is what we get..." are useless.
Useful links
herman at cs dot ru dot nl